top of page

References:

McMahan, I. & Thompson, S. (2015). Adolescence: Canadian Edition. Toronto: Pearson. 

Meta-Reflection: Topic 6 and Topic 7 - Community, Culture, Media, and Gender

Critical thinking is a major focus in education, developing and using critical thinking to examine everything from curricular material to our own lives. Inclusive education requires us to examine our perceptions of students and the diversity created through their unique experiences, perspectives, and identities. People are complex and every individual operates within their own unique set of influencing factors (McMahan and Thompson, 2015, p. 230). These factors include the communities, cultures, and medias that each individual participates in or has been influenced by. Bronfenbrenner's (1989) ecological systems theory is one way to conceptualize these complexities (p. 230). Local communities are the "ecosystem" and the broader culture, subculture, or social class in which communities are located are the "macrosystems" (p. 230). Media is everywhere in our technological society, influencing and being influenced by every system in Bronfenbrenner's theory.

 

I have grown up within a "western" context since I was born in Alberta, Canada, to caucasian parents whose families have been in North America since early colonization. This means that I have not experienced the cultural atmospheres of other geographical locations. The cultural context I have experienced, a "western" cultural context, has supported certain beliefs and values about the world, and about identity. One important aspect of an individual's identity is their views and beliefs about gender. Gender is a socially constructed concept and gender roles are "a set of shared cultural expectations that outlines the attitudes and behaviors a typical male or female should display" (p. 268), which links gender to community, culture and media. The process of creating gender in a "western" culture begins at, or even before, birth as babies are assigned a "sex" and parents begin collecting the blue/masculine objects that are for a baby "boy" or pink/feminine objects that are for a baby "girl". The arbitrary connection between the biological sex assigned at birth, the gender of the individual, and the types of objects and activities they will prefer is created by the interactions between community, culture, and media. "Western" culture has created these stereotypes, the media reinforces them, and individuals internalize them so that they will belong to the larger community. Each of us has "a need to belong" (McMahan and Thompson, 2015, p. 231) and this desire for a sense of community can drive our actions, influence our beliefs and values, and cause us to actively or passively perpetuate the same cultural conditions.

 

These cultural conditions, these gender stereotypes can be limiting or even deadly to some individuals. So, as a teacher, I need to be aware of these conditions and stereotypes, and how perceived conformity or non-conformity effects individuals. I also need to teach my students to think critically about our class materials, the world around them, and the possible interactions. All students should feel their identity is accepted and valued, that no part of who they are is a handicap or a reason to feel ashamed. The movement towards safe and caring schools and inclusive education are part of the changes made to the Education Act and should be part of every schools policy. 

 

My classes will encourage critical thinking and challenge adolescents to question their own beliefs and values as well as those of other communities and cultures. The materials below could potentially be analysed by teachers, parents, and adolescents, as they are all interconnected. Scrolling down you will see:

  • Bronfenbrenner's (1989) ecological systems theory model - one way to understand the interactions between individuals and their surroundings

  • Alberta Educations vision for inclusive education in a video series - the videos themselves are a great resource and the website as a whole is an important source of information, policy, and legislation for all parties interested in education

  • Resources on inclusive education from Medicine Hat and Edmonton Public School Board - understanding how different schools realise inclusive education is important and can inform your own process of creating an inclusive classroom

  • A list of resources pertaining to inclusive education, the adolescent brain, gender, and gender neutral/inclusive education - could be relevant for teachers, parents and, adolescents

  • Additional resources I might use in my classroom - all of the information presented below could be shared with the class and analyzed by students, but these resources could spark more focused discussions about how community, culture, media, and gender are linked (we could also include other factors of identity, beliefs/values, political issues/movements, and any other topics students are passionate about or feel are relevant to our discussion)   

 

Edmonton Public addresses inclusive education on their website. They have embedded an interesting video series into their website, in addition to providing links to important resources. Look below for the video from EPSB. 

Medicine Hat has a great online toolbox for looking at inclusive education. This toolbox includes information, videos, and links to other great resources. Alberta Education has policies and guidelines for inclusive education, but each school district might conceptualize and implement these in slightly different ways. 

Bronfenbrenner's (1989) ecological systems theory

Bronfenbrenner's (1989) ecological systems theory. This diagram shows one way to conceptualize the complexities that influence and are influenced by individuals.  

The video to the left of this box, comments on the arbitrary assignment of gender stereotypes based on the sex that is assigned to infants at birth, or before depending on the use of ultrasounds, and how these stereotypes should not be our only understanding of sex and gender. 

The video to the right of this box outlines the "western" gender stereotypes created for the gender binary, where "boys" have specific traits and "girls" have a different set of specific traits. Then the video focusses on complexity, the number of differences between individuals and, the limitless options for identity. 

I could ask students to explore the BlendSpace that I created about GSA's in our schools, to choose one (if it is a policy document, an article or a complex website) or two (if one is an image or short video) and to create a representation of their analysis of their chosen resource(s). These resources could also be explored in class for the purpose of whole-class and small group discussions. These discussions could form the foundation for analyzing curriculum materials, historical contexts, current affairs, and any other representation of gender (aspects of identity, beliefs/values, stereotypes, and any other relevant topic).

The videos above could be utilized in my classroom to generate discussion, to expand understandings, as the focus of an assignment, to create connections between materials. Part of inclusive education is the understanding that no singular learning style works for every individual. This makes sense as identity is unique to each individual, and is constantly changing as the individual influences and is influenced by their ecosystem, their social and cultural context.

 

Students could create Identity Charts for characters, prominent figures, themselves, or any other identity. For example, in an English class, students could create identity charts for themselves and then for a character, analysing similarities and differences, how relationships influence identity, the social and cultural contexts in which the identity forms, and other components of that influence identity.   

The video to the left of this box discusses closets, and how we all have them. The "hard" conversations do not just refer to "coming out" as being gay, but to conversations about divorce, death, and any other topic that is difficult to discuss openly. 

 

What is your closet? What closets might exist for others (could examine this in relation to a text)? Have you had a "hard" conversation?  

The video to the right of this box is an exaggerated representation of gender stereotypes and gender roles, but it could spark discussion. 

 

What gender stereotypes have you seen in media, products, public spaces, private spaces, the workplace, or any other source? Do you agree with them? Why or why not? 

The videos to the left of this box show compilations of media clips that reinforce gender stereotypes. 

 

Critically analyze these clips, considering the images, and language used, and the message created. Is there a common stereotype? Is there a common message? Is gender portrayed as positive or negative? 

 

Students could analyze other texts and media. They could consider historical contexts. They could examine gender over time or across contexts. 

 

Can you find an example of media that does not reinforce gender stereotypes, or breaks/subverts gender stereotypes?

The video to the right of this box mentions how companies market their products towards gender. Start by considering the connections between "girls", pink, and dolls, and between "boys", blue, and superheroes. Then consider other products, markets, and spaces that create similar gender stereotypes. 

 

Why does this happen? Can identity really be pared down to two clear categories? 

Sara

© 2023 by  Designs by Thomas Rider. Proudly created with Wix.com

Tinney

Contact Me

Questions spark conversations and conversations spark learning.

Success! Message received.

bottom of page